Source: TH
Context:
The publication, in February 2024, of a household consumption survey by the National Sample Survey (NSS) Office, after a gap of over a decade, has made it possible to estimate the poverty rate in India.
What is Primary Food Consumption?
- The basic minimum food intake required to ensure energy, protein, and micronutrient sufficiency for a healthy life.
- Components:
- Cereals (carbohydrates)
- Pulses (protein)
- Vegetables (vitamins & minerals)
- Fats (energy)
- Milk/curd (calcium & micronutrients)
- Metric Used: Thali Index – a standard South Asian meal (rice/roti, dal, vegetables, curd, salad).
Features of Primary Food Consumption
- Balanced Nutrition: Goes beyond calorie sufficiency; ensures carbs–protein–micronutrient balance.
- Universal Baseline: Sets a minimum desirable consumption level for all citizens.
- Affordability Sensitive: Considers residual spending power after non-food essentials (rent, transport, health).
- Equity-Oriented: Benchmarks disparities in food access.
- Policy-Relevant: Provides a realistic yardstick for PDS design and subsidy targeting.
Current Reality (NSS 2024 Survey)
- Food affordability gap:
- Nearly 50% of rural India cannot afford 2 thalis/day.
- About 20% of urban India also fall short.
- PDS impact: Reduces deprivation but insufficient to fill the protein gap.
- Cereal equality: Rich and poor consume nearly the same cereals → PDS success in cereals.
- Pulses gap: Bottom 5% consume half the pulses of the top 5% → protein deprivation persists.
Public Distribution System (PDS)
- Achievements:
- Equalised cereal consumption across socio-economic groups.
- Gaps:
- Protein deficiency remains unaddressed.
- Pulses missing from PDS in adequate measure.
- Inefficiencies:
- 80% coverage → even non-poor get cereals.
- High FCI stocking, fiscal strain.
- Urban vs Rural:
- Urban subsidies more progressive.
- Rural subsidies disproportionately benefit higher-expenditure households.
- Policy Overhang: Cereal entitlements exceed actual needs → wasteful subsidy burden.
Challenges in Equalising Food Consumption
- Fiscal Stress: Large cereal subsidies crowd out funds for nutrition diversification.
- Nutritional Deficit: Protein-energy malnutrition, anaemia, stunting persist despite cereal sufficiency.
- Logistics: Storage, buffer stocking, and transport of pulses are more complex.
- Targeting Errors: Leakages, wrong inclusion/exclusion reduce efficiency.
- Behavioural Factors: Food habits and awareness may limit uptake of nutrient-rich foods.
Restructuring PDS for Nutrition Security
- Rationalise Cereal Entitlement:
- Reduce rice/wheat quotas to match actual consumption of bottom deciles.
- Diversify Food Basket:
- Add pulses, millets, fortified oils, iodised salt.
- Promote balanced nutrition, not just cereal sufficiency.
- Remove Top-End Subsidies:
- Withdraw subsidies for top 20% consumption fractile.
- Free fiscal space for nutrition support.
- Dynamic Targeting:
- Use Aadhaar + SECC data for updated beneficiary lists.
- Leverage Technology:
- GPS-enabled grain movement, DBT for pulses, e-POS systems for accountability.
